Calculators and Calculating Devices
||Topic Tree | Home|
|Calculators in the Classroom|
|The Slide Rule|
Counting rods were first used in ancient times to quickly perform arithmetic. The counting rods could be transported easily and made calculations accessible to many people.
The illustration above shows how the digits were expressed in counting rods. The rods were inverted for every other place, so a horizontal bar followed by a vertical bar would be 11
Some claim the origin of the abacus to be Babylonia where people drew marks in a sandbox. Sandboxes gave way to trays with lines and eventually grooved trays with balls.
Grooved trays were introduced into China by the Han Dynasty period (206 B.C - 220 A.D.) During the Ming Dynasty (1368-1636) the rod abacus was developed.
One source says the Egyptians developed rod and bead abacuses as early as 500 B.C. With the Chinese and Japanese counterparts emerging in the second century A.D.
The Chinese rod abacus, suan phan, uses a series of rods containing seven beads. The beads of each rod are divided into a group of two (heaven) and a group of five (earth) by a bar.
The Japanese rod abacus, soroban, is similar except only one bead appears on each rod above the bar, followed by five below.
The abacus provides students with many advantages including an understanding of the base-10 number system. It also helps to promote mental math.
Many adept students of the abacus can figure problems with great speed and accuracy. In November of 1946, the abacus was positioned against the latest electric calculator in a contest of speed. The abacus won 4 out of 5 tasks, only losing in straight multiplication. The full account can be found reprinted at The Abacus
Contributed by Sara Collins
CALCULATOR: a mechanical, electromechanical, or electronic device that performs arithmetic operations automatically.
Since the first hand-held electronic calculator appeared on the market nearly 30 years ago, individuals and special interest groups have voiced extremely strong opinion, both pro and con, regarding the use of calculators in the classroom. And the debate continues today. David Gelernter, professor of computer science at Yale University, believes calculators should be totally eliminated from the classroom. He feels that allowing children to use calculators produces adults who can't do basic arithmetic, doomed to wander through life in a numeric haze. In 1997, California legislation would prohibit the use of calculators in schools prior to the sixth grade. Whereas, the state of Virginia purchased 200,000 graphing calculators to be used by all middle school and high school math students.
"According to the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM), the use of calculators along with traditional paper-and-pencil instruction enhances the learning of basic skills." In fact, the NCTM supports "the integration of the calculator into the school mathematics program at all grade levels in class work, homework, and evaluation." (Roberts, 1991, p.51) In other words, the use of calculators should not eliminate the teaching of the basic algorithmic skills and processes of mathematics. It should be properly integrated to reinforce the basic concepts that are being taught and to aid in the application of these math processes to real-world situations. The key words here are "proper integration". This implies teacher-supervised activities relating to the mathematical concepts being learned.
One of the problems experienced with children who have used calculators from an early age without proper integration is that they have not had the opportunity to develop good "number sense". This is sometimes referred to as a "feel for numbers". The importance of estimating an answer before or after calculating is not understood. Why estimate, when the calculator will give you the exact answer? After all, a calculator is never wrong. That is virtually true, but the operator of the calculator is capable of error. And a mislocated decimal point can make quite a difference, as illustrated below.
Also we must not ignore one of the primary reasons we teach math--it trains the mind. It promotes logical and rational thinking skills and discipline. It requires using learned information to proceed to the next level of information, whether it be dealing with numbers or ideas. These types of thinking skills are imperative if students are to be able to function as thinking, intelligent, contributing members of society: the ultimate goal of education.
Many studies have been conducted and articles written regarding the use of calculators in all levels of classrooms. At least four that apply specifically to middle schools are found in Impact of Calculators on Mathematics Instruction, edited by George W. Bright, Hersholt C. Waxman and Susan E. Williams. Another source that contains articles on the positive impact and potential of calculators in the classroom is the NCTM 1992 Yearbook, edited by James T. Fey and Christian R. Hirsch. This book also contains at least three articles that look specifically at middle schools. Several of these studies support the theory that students allowed to use calculators in math classes produced higher achievement scores in problem-solving as well as basic skills. Students also had a much more positive attitude toward mathematics when allowed to use calculators. Sometimes that attitude can mean the difference between failure and success in math, especially for a student who has continually struggled with the basic skills. The question no longer seems to be whether or not to integrate the calculator into the classroom, but how to wisely use it as yet another tool to reach as many students as possible.
Contributed by Nancy Ayers
The slide rule is a mechanical device used for calculating the complex operations of multiplication, division, square roots, cube roots, and trigonometry, but cannot be used to complete simple addition and subtraction problems. The accuracy of the computation depends upon the size of the slide rule with the commonly used 10-inch slide rule having accuracy to 3 significant figures. Longer slide rules can have accuracy up to 4 significant figures but are not convenient to work with. The 6-inch slide rule is easy to work with but is not as accurate as the other slide rules. Computational problem solving with the slide rule is now obsolete with the introduction of the calculator.
History of the Slide Rule
Credit is given to two separate individuals for the invention of the slide rule: Edmund Gunther (1581-1626) and William Oughtred (1574-1660), both English ministers who enjoyed the study of mathematics. Gunter was a professor of astronomy at Gresham College in London and devised "Gunter's Line" which is a logarithmic line of numbers. Oughtred designed a pair of sliding scales to be used in conjunction with one another. He also invented a circular slide rule that had two radial pointers pivoted at the center of the rule in which logarithmic distances could be added and subtracted.
Sir Isaac Newton suggested a runner for the slide rule, but none was invented until a century later. Several other distinguished mathematicians contributed to the evolution of the slide rule-Seth Partridge in 1657 invented the slide as we now know it, James Watt and Boulton in 1775 devised the "Soho" ruler and John Robertson around 1775 developed an intricate slide rule with a runner similar to the slide rules presently used.
The most common type of slide rule, Mannheim Slide Rule, was named for Lt. Amedee Mannheim (1831-1906), a French army officer from Paris, who used the slide rule to calculate artillery fire. He later became Professor of Geometry at the Ecole Polytechnique in Paris. He is noted for standardizing the slide rule and devising a cylindrical slide rule considered more accurate than his straight slide rule.
The United States interest in the Mannheim Slide Rule escalated in the later 1800's. In 1880, Washington University in St. Louis was the first college in the United States to require their engineering students to use slide rules for numerical computations. United States manufactures, Keuffel and Esser, began producing slide rules in 1887.
Parts of the Slide Rule
Numerous books and instruction manuals have been written for educational purposes in learning the proper method for using the slide rule in problem solving calculations. With the introduction of the calculator, the historical applications to the advancement of calculating devices are the only practical purpose of the slide rule today.
Contributed by Judy Lasater